At 180 degrees idle becomes noticeably rougher


http://209.208.111.198/Topic27763.aspx
Print Topic | Close Window

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
The engine runs 155 to 160 with a 180 degree thermostat, unless idling at long stoplights.  At the lower temp idle is perfect, smooth, 600 rpm.  It is pretty cool, actually relaxing with a point in there where a deep base note rolls through.  When the water temp gauge hits 180 the idle changes, very predictably.  Same thing each time...  rougher, uneven. 

I have noticed the coil is hot.  It is an Accel with internal 1.4 ohm resistence without ballast, which was the coil Accel called for to go with their pointless ingition if ballast resistor wasnt going to be used.  Coil is mounted in standard location over intake, with 1/2 in. spacers holding it above intake.

Intake manifold gaskets are wide open at the crossover, and they and the manifold are temporaries waiting for Mummert's release.  Thin stock phenolic spacer between intake and carb.

So what do you think is the cause in idle change?  Heating causing a change in idle mixture or an overheated coil changing its characteristics?  Idle returns to normal immediately after temp drops. 

By charliemccraney - 16 Years Ago
First, verify that the temp is actually 180 with an infrared thermometer. You may have a similar problem as I which is insufficient airflow at idle to keep the engine cool. If it is a cooling issue, you may find it difficult to get a consistent idle.



Assuming it is cooling properly, I think your idle mixture needs to be adjusted - probably leaner.
By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
Charlie, the temp gauge is a quality Autometer, and is dead accurate according to infrared thermometer.

When it goes up to say 175 I switch on the elect. fan and the engine will stay at 180 until back underway.

Leaner? 

By charliemccraney - 16 Years Ago
If the mixture is too rich, it may run well when it's cooler under the ho.. wait, do you have a hood? As it warms up, it is too rich because the air is hotter - less air gets into the engine. Idle it in your driveway until it starts to run rough and adjust the idle screws to see if it improves.
By GREENBIRD56 - 16 Years Ago
How about .....change the electrical parts to see if you can rule them out - space the coil off the engine more than a half inch or something like that. Use an old coil and resistor for a temporary replacement. The Accel trigger is just a power transistor that goes to ground like points - at idle a less juicy coil shouldn't be a big deal for it. As long as the total resistance is over 1.4 OHMS (coil and resistor).

Use your infared gun on the carburetor, hard fuel lines and fuel fillter. Mechanical fuel pump? If the engine is thumping along sort of retarded on spark - the exhaust will heat up and start "radiating" everything in the "line of sight' from the heated surfaces. Fuel pressure maybe dropping?

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
Charlie and AZ, thanks.  It will take a few days to go through all your suggestions.  Oh, it is hoodless.

Mike

By Unibodyguy - 16 Years Ago
Mike I had a simular problem with my truck when it got warmed up, but I had to slightly "fatten" up the mixture and it smoothed right out. But I'm also at a 2000-2500 ft. altitude also. It also ran a little fast after doing this at idle but after warming up went down to 650-700 RPM and thats with a hand choke.

                                                        Michael

By paul2748 - 16 Years Ago
I had a problem similar to yours after finishing a cross country trip in my TBird. Good idle when cool, lousy idle when hot. After much trial and error, I found that the lash on the exhaust valves had closed up. After resetting the valves, the idle was much improved. Apparently, the long trip pounded the seats (probably not hardened seats) . The same problem is coming back, so I am doing a valve job and getting the hardened seats.



Check the valve lash.
By Pete 55Tbird - 16 Years Ago
Hello; You said you have a 180degree thermostat and you car idles good until it come up to temp of 180 degrees and then it runs not so good. This is just after the thermostat open. Coincidence? Or hot water in the intake manifold raising the temp of the carb. Are you using E85 or gas with ethanol?
By pegleg - 16 Years Ago
[quote]Pete 55Tbird (6/14/2009)
Hello; You said you have a 180degree thermostat and you car idles good until it come up to temp of 180 degrees and then it runs not so good. This is just after the thermostat open. Coincidence? Or hot water in the intake manifold raising the temp of the carb.

     And making it act rich. That's why Charlie told him to reset the idle hot. Problem is, when he does, it will be lean before it warms up. It's a tradeoff.

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
All the input is appreciated!  Today I raised the coil another 1/4 in., and bought my own IFR thermometer.  Unfortunately the ballast resistor on the shelf has a broken insulator that the winding goes around, so may have to get another to try the stock coil/ballast setup.  Need one anyway to carry in the glove box.  Didnt have a chance to do anything else.  Lash should be fine, but will check again, this time at 180.  Previously have always adjusted lash to cold spec.

The cold running temp is a continuing puzzle.  The same temperatures occurred with the previous low compression engine, using a big 4 row stock 1946 new core radiator.  Put in a new engine with much higher CR, a relatively small 17X19 core alum. rad, and the same thing.  I talked to a mech. engineer/car nut about it last year.  He thought the cold temp was due to the low 7:1 or so CR.  It is now clear that wasnt right, because the CR is approx. 9.2:1.

I am lucky to have one of Franks aluminum timing covers and water pumps.  Several years ago when I was installing them, there was interference in the area of the timing cover water scraper (dont know what it should be called), and the pump impeller.  After some work clearance was achieved with a very close tolerance that could be measured in thousandths.  Perhaps the result is a super efficient, maybe too efficient pumping action, leading to cool running temps?  Sounds a little far out but nobody else has been able to explain the phenom. 

Mike

By Hoosier Hurricane - 16 Years Ago
Mike:

Where is the temperature sensor installed?

By Ted - 16 Years Ago
I’ve found that the engine temperature reading on a Y is lower than the thermostat rating if you are taking the reading at the back of the head in the stock location.  I typically see about a ~10° to ~15° difference in temperature readings from the rear to the front of the engine on a Y.  Moving the temperature sensor to the heater water port right behind the thermostat typically gives a more accurate reading or it comes closer to matching the rating of the thermostat.
By pegleg - 16 Years Ago
Ted,

       That makes absolute sense. the coolant continues to absorb heat as it travels to the front of the motor. The hottest point should be at the thermostat. I can easily believe a 15 degree rise from the back to the outlet.

         Mike, I intentionally kept the impeller to the timing cover dimensions tight, but had some issues with the machine shop not locating the mounting holes in the pump/timing cover accurately. I finally had to change suppliers because of that. I hand fitted the pumps to the cover just to avoid the issue. Not sure how yours slipped through, but I apologize, you shouldn't have had to do that.   

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
John, the sender is on the DS in rear of head.  Today I'll do some testing with the handy thermo and report.  Also will try some slight adjustments on idle screws to find the happy compromise. 
By GREENBIRD56 - 16 Years Ago
I usually try to get my IR readings right on the thermostat housing. That has to be the hottest water in the engine. My other favorite spot is the waterpump inlet - temp in / temp out and the ambient outdoor surrounding temp (air going into the radiator and carb inlet) usually tells the tale.
By Nat Santamaria - 16 Years Ago
I find my 312 Y block in my 57 T-bird runs better when it is hotter. When the needle is pointing about 2/3 rds in the white band area the cars pulls away from a light with a clean, crisp acceleration and seems to be a bit more power. I am running a 170 wide opening thermostat from Casco.
By DANIEL TINDER - 16 Years Ago
pegleg (6/15/2009)
Ted,





I intentionally kept the impeller to the timing cover dimensions tight, but had some issues with the machine shop not locating the mounting holes in the pump/timing cover accurately. I finally had to change suppliers because of that. I hand fitted the pumps to the cover just to avoid the issue. Not sure how yours slipped through, butI apologize, you shouldn't have had to do that.




Ted,



Funny, it never occurred to me to trial-fit the alum. components when I received them a few years back (put aside for inevitable rebuild).

The pump-to-spacer clearance is VERY tight. You said was intentional, but did not explain (?). As is, I would certainly have to move the pump around and feel for contact before final gasket-seal/torquing.

On the cover, though I see evidence of finish grinding, if not a T-Bird I would be in big trouble without further alteration! Not even close.

I also notice quite a divergence in the way bolt holes & and casting edges of the 3 items align. I see my FoMoCo parts do not line up perfect either though, and the wider gaskets do sort of break up the misalignment some.



So, should I grind on the cover some more to make some breathing room, or just pre-assemble & seal before final cover install? What should target spacer-to-pump clearance be?
By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
Today was another learning chapter in the book of Y's.  Too bad the chapters arent in sequence.  Went for a short ride and found a shade tree when the gauge hit 155:

DS rear of head right next to sender     158

DS front of head 182

PS front of head 188

Intake crossover 160

Intake water jacket 170

Water port behind thermo housing 167

Thermo housing 170

Carb body 101

Coil 122

So, as suggested by Ted and John, the water gauge is approx. 15 deg. cool due to its location.  And the rough idle doesnt start at 180, but 195 or 200 deg., which seems to make more sense. 

I'll move the sender to behind the stat when the new manifold is installed.  In the meantime the fan will get switched on earlier, and maybe that alone will take care of rough idle.  The carb and coil temps seemed good, but dont have anything to compare them to.

A couple years ago a friend checked the rear DS head & thermo housing temps, and they were virtually identical being below 160 degrees after I had driven to his house 12 miles away.  But the old engine had some weird issues.

Thanks to everyone for their help!

Mike

By charliemccraney - 16 Years Ago
My gauge is the same. It reads 160 in the cab but just before the thermostat it is about 188 according to ir.
By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
It is always interesting watching threads like this when others have the problem.  One system seems to be more or less doing well and not an issue, out of the picture.  Other problems are aired that look to be safely removed from the good system, and everything ends up turning back.
By DANIEL TINDER - 16 Years Ago
DANIEL TINDER (6/15/2009)
[quote]pegleg (6/15/2009)
Ted,







What should target spacer-to-pump (impeller) clearance be?






Opps. Question should have been addressed to Frank. Sorry.
By pegleg - 16 Years Ago
Dan,

        I attempt to get the clearance between .020 & .030" this is an arbitrary number I chose to eliminate as much leakage between the impeller and the casting as I could. Need to keep some clearance because the impeller will grow with heat more rapidly than the timing cover. I've seen rebuilt iron pumps with over .060" that still pumped water. 

      All of the timing cover castings will show evidence of grinding. This is to remove a core to pattern mismatch. The clearance issue always seem to be at the start of the volute, which is the closest point of contact.  

By DANIEL TINDER - 16 Years Ago
Frank,



It would seem that pre-assembling/sealing pump to spacer before final installation on cover is dictated (if impeller-to-spacer clearance IS truly critical)?

I had assumed the impeller-to-pump body spec. was important, but since the impeller is so far from the cover volute on a T-Bird, and the larger impeller-to-cover volume space has apparently been proven moot by past testing of the once touted backing-plate accessory(?), this is indeed a revelation.
By pegleg - 16 Years Ago
Dan,

       I've had this discussion with a number of folks, including some from the Classic T'Bird club. The area behind the impeller, or the size of the plenum has no effect on how the pump works. The pump works by spinning the impeller, this throws the water out of the area betweem the blades. That is replaced by more water from the supply side (the radiator). Exhausted water, after it is thrown out of the impeller, is forced into the plenum and then the engine. The only restriction to this flow should be the thermostat.

      The plate that you refer to, has only one purpose, to make money for whomever sells it.Cool 

By Eddie Paskey - 16 Years Ago
Dan  

     Casco has a very interesting article on that plate,  Had one on my bird.. didn't work worth beans!!!  Now have large impeller, smaller pulley, clutch fan and large hole 170 thermostat--  also have A/C condensor under right front fender with elect fan. Even in parades never goes over 190.  Hope this helps!!     God bless    Eddie

By DANIEL TINDER - 16 Years Ago
[quote]pegleg (6/15/2009)
Ted,







I intentionally kept the impeller to the timing cover dimensions tight,



Ted,



Description of pump action exactly as I had assumed. So, am still puzzled by your previous statement re: impeller-to-cover clearance?

If pressure source comes from under the impeller vanes, aside from minimum clearance, why should it matter?
By DANIEL TINDER - 16 Years Ago
Crap! Did it again! NOT Ted, but FRANK.
By pegleg - 16 Years Ago
Dan,

     Look at the timing cover, and remember the pump was designed for the car, not the Bird. The volute and the shape is designed to direct water into the the TC passage.  

By DANIEL TINDER - 16 Years Ago
Frank,



So, due to the fact that the impeller is so far from the cover volute with the T-Bird spacer, I should assume that only safe minimum impeller-to-casting clearance is important in my case (?), and your "tight" design specs. were intended for max. efficiency when the cover alone is used?
By pegleg - 16 Years Ago
Dan,

          I think that was already done to your spacer. If not then you can return it and I will or you can check the clearance yourself and let me know what's who.

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
Today the wife and friends carravaned on a poker run.  The engine ran great, but the idle problem came up.  Ambient temps were up, and when the water temp hit 180 for extended periods in town (meaning 195), the engine started crapping out.  At one point in Ashland I was real worried, as it stalled at a stop light.  Luckily got it fired back up.

Not long later came to one of the pickup points and there was a long line, the temp rose, and stall.  Couldnt start so rolled back down the hill and went in to get the cards, checked the coil and it was hot.  Immediately started on return.

I am sure it is the coil.  It is an Accel with 1.4 ohms internal resist., no ballast required.  I feel like a dumby, because this is the third of these crap coils that have been problems.  Plan to replace with a OEM unit and resistor this week.

Before the run I rechecked the valve adj. and they were all fine. 

By 55vickey - 16 Years Ago
I have a flamethrower coil with no ballast resister and it also gets extremely hot. Everything with the engine is super until it gets hot then I usually put it in nuetral while at a stop light to keep it from stalling. Fires right back up but it is very temperature sensitive. Is it normal for the coil to be so hot? Usually run at 180+ on the highway and highway driving is great, but it's the idle area that gets touchy when its hot. Gary
By Hoosier Hurricane - 16 Years Ago
46 Y block:

Sounds more like vapor lock than electrical to me.

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
John,  There is an elect. fuel pump with gas line running under the back part of the intake, and coming up through the center area where the hold downs are, then to the front of the Autolite.  The line is wrapped with adhesive backed fiberglass insulation from down in the hold down area to within an inch or so of the carb. 

55Vickey, The first flamethrower of this number I ended up using on my 54 Ford tractor when it was first converted to 12V.  It was always hot when in use, and gave out in 1-2 years.  The second overheated and puked its oil when I left the ignition on overnight, but it was hot while in use during its short life.  My thinking was that with the Accel pointless ignition matched to one of their coils they specified in the instructions, it should be a great match this time around.

By Hoosier Hurricane - 16 Years Ago
46:

That fuel line is located in probably the hottest part of the top of the engine.  I recommend temporarily running a line on the topside of the intake and see if that makes a difference.  Even with fiberglass insulation, the heat would be trememdous under the center of the manifold.  It burns the paint off the manifolds.

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
Thanks John, I'll try it. 
By 63 Red Stake Bed - 16 Years Ago
46,

I searched through this thread & didn't find what you have for a carb spacer, & what carb you are using.  I saw something about autolite, & remember from before you had planned on using a 2barrel, but think it may be relevent to find out what the application of that carb is, & what you have for a spacer/insulator. 

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
63 Red Stake Bed (6/20/2009)
46,

I searched through this thread & didn't find what you have for a carb spacer, & what carb you are using.  I saw something about autolite, & remember from before you had planned on using a 2barrel, but think it may be relevent to find out what the application of that carb is, & what you have for a spacer/insulator. 

The carb is an autolite 2100 which originally would have been used on a Mustang SBF, 1966 if I remember right.  There is a half inch phenolic spacer between it and the intake.  This probably doesnt have any bearing, but I rotated the automatic choke spring so that the choke never is activated, always open.  Carb was newly rebuilt before installation.

Mike

By 63 Red Stake Bed - 16 Years Ago
Might be fruitless, but if your coil solution doesn't work, I'd also try swapping out the carb for something different.  A good baseline would be an autolite that is specific to an original y block application.  Or try one of the 2300 holley's that came on trucks from late 50's through 64. 

I recently swapped out an old 2100 that was of 68 small block ford application that was on two different y's I've messed with over the years with a 58 holley 2300 & was surprised how much the idle through 2500 response & light to part throttle driving changed. 

The only down fall of the autolite 2100's is the fact that the idle, low & high speed air bleeds are built in to the boosters & also the carb castings.  The worst thing is there is very little information availible to properly understand what boosters with which carb produce accurate meetering with which engine, & then if you factor in the changes that occur with a 100 degree fuel bowl, & what each air bleed does or doesn't do when the carb is 100 degrees it stands to reason as to why most end up with new carbs, & or application specific remanufatured carbs. 

By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
I have thought about upgrading to a 2300  350 cfm, but only because of the increased flow.  The engine should jump to 4000 faster than currently.  However money is getting scarce.  I really dont think the carb design or size is the problem, it is the 1.14 venturi compared to the original 1.02, approx. 300 cfm vs. 240.  Spark plugs have been looking very good, slightly on the lean side.  Increased the main jets from 52 to 53.  I havent gone through a WOT and immediate shutdown yet to check plugs under those conditions.  Also plan to follow Charlie's advice to slightly lean up the idle mixture, but havent done it even though it is the easiest of all tasks.  Thanks for the interest 63. 
By 46yblock - 16 Years Ago
Sorry for dragging this up again, but thought a more or less final report should be made. 

I rerouted the gas line so it stays well above the intake.  Also changed the coil to an OEM with ballast.

This weekend on a 60 mile run up I-5 and back, gauge temp rose to 180, as the tall climbs were made.  On return home there were three long periods of idle at 180.  Quality never deteriorated on idle.  After in the barn, checked the thermo housing temp and it was 187 with gauge at 180, maybe a couple degrees more.  The OEM coil was 147.

Soooo, the sender will remain in the stock location.  The problem looks like it is fixed on the idle.  

I tinkered around with the mainjets too, and maybe created a new issue.  The car behind me said whenever I put the foot to the throttle black smoke came out both exhausts, at highway speeds of 65-75.  So my thinking is either the jets are a tad too large, or they are on the fringe and the pump shot is excessive.   Ambient temp may have played a roll, as it was COLD the entire first leg of the trip, being about 50 degrees.  Unfortunately I was at the tail of the convoy on return, when temps outside were 95, with nobody to see what was happening.