I refuse to use those 'stick-through' plastic things to mount an electric fan, so I made steel brackets that attach the fan to my four radiator bolts.Many aftermarket fans butt right up against the radiator, so you really don't need a shroud (the fan housing IS the shroud).
I also used a 16" diameter, and glad I did. The most airflow happens at the fan blade tips because they are at the highest velocity.
Now, I realize more HP because the fan doesn't run until it's needed. No more worries about idling for extended lengths of time in stuck traffic or overheating in cruises.