braided vs neoprene crank seals


http://209.208.111.198/Topic37097.aspx
Print Topic | Close Window

By jonnireb - 15 Years Ago
Hello guys,

I finally joined after several years of lurking. I have had

y blocks off and on since the sixties, but I have never used

neoprene seals. How are they? Are they any advantage over

braidsed? I woule appreciate any advice.

By Glen Henderson - 15 Years Ago
First let me welcome you to the site. I like the neoprene seals, no more cutting and fitting the rope. The engine guru's will give you more imput, but I love them.
By Ted - 15 Years Ago

And another welcome to the site.

 

My vote is for neoprene.  The Y is not as simple as one would believe in eliminating oil leaks at the back of the engine.  On the rope seals, a little leakage from the seal itself beginning at the initial install until the seal swells up with oil is normal.  Engines that aren’t driven very often will also have a tendency for leakage with the rope seals.  On the flip side, the seal surface on the crankshaft must be in good condition for a neoprene seal to do its job.  Here’s a link giving detailed instructions on installing neoprene seals.

Neoprene seal installation tips

By paul2748 - 15 Years Ago
I helped a guy put one of the neoprene seals in his 57 TBird, which was a real leaker. It dried everything up and is holding .



The guy who built my 312 in my 54 used a neoprene seal in the rebuild about three years ago. No leaks from this area. Wish I could say the same for the valley cover.
By oldcarmark - 15 Years Ago
Ted! Thanks for showing that info on rear main seal installation.I am going to be using the Best rear seal on my rebuild and your information will certainly help to install it properly and avoid leaks especially sealing those pan bolts which I never would have thought about.Without a doubt you are one of the most knowledgeable Y guys in the world.I have a tip for anyone looking to replace the rope type seal on the car and cant get the upper half out of the block.If you screw a sheetmetal screw into the end of the seal it will give a grip for vicegrips.Have someone turn the motor over by hand and pull on the seal at the same time.It should come right out.How about some tips on sealing the valley cover as Paul has mentioned?
By jonnireb - 15 Years Ago
thanks a lot,everybody. I usually have always had a bit

of seepage at the crank seal,but figured it was pretty much

normal. Had one in a 55 merc that poured,but rebuilt the

engine and the new stuff held pretty well. I had'nt ever

heard of neoprene seals for Ys at that time(1965). I  will

give them a try next time. thanks again.

By paul2748 - 15 Years Ago
Just for your information, Best Gasket has a new type of rope seal made out of some other material than the old type. Saw it in a article in Street Rodder.
By PF Arcand - 15 Years Ago
Mark: thanks for the upper seal removal tip. However, nearly all the info posted here about seal replacement is about doing it on the "bench," not in chassis. Despite it being obviously more difficult, do you have any advice on reinstalling an upper seal, neoprene or rope type, in the car? Thanks
By unibodyboy - 15 Years Ago
Paul2748,



Hey I also had a problem with my valley cover leaking. It was an older style composition gasket. I replaced it with a new neoprene gasket, and it sealed much better this time. Not sure which you have, but it was definitely worth replacing for me.
By aussiebill - 15 Years Ago
unibodyboy (1/4/2010)
Paul2748,

Hey I also had a problem with my valley cover leaking. It was an older style composition gasket. I replaced it with a new neoprene gasket, and it sealed much better this time. Not sure which you have, but it was definitely worth replacing for me.

Greg, looks like you have your valley leak fixed! but it is worth the time to place a straight edge along the sealing edges and check for straightness, as usually the corners are bent up and hence cannot seal properly, the oil filler corner allways is bent the worst due to the oil cap being banged down hard and strangled to remove and the tube allways catches on things when engine is being moved etc. I have years back drilled and tapped the 4 corners and fitted small bolts, but good straight edges should seal properly. best regards bill.

By oldcarmark - 15 Years Ago
Hello Paul.Just a couple of things I remember from doing a rear main on my 289 about 20+ years ago.It helps if you loosen off the main cap bolts to allow a little less tension on the crank.As you push the upper half into place try to compress the seal as you install it and try very hard not to knick the back of the seal on the sharp edge of the block.Last tip would be keep your mouth closed as you are lying under the motor unless you like the taste of motor oil.
By paul2748 - 15 Years Ago
unibodyboy (1/4/2010)
Paul2748,



Hey I also had a problem with my valley cover leaking. It was an older style composition gasket. I replaced it with a new neoprene gasket, and it sealed much better this time. Not sure which you have, but it was definitely worth replacing for me.




Thanks - If I have to pull the intake, then I am going with the machine screw at the corners.
By paul2748 - 15 Years Ago
PF Arcand (1/3/2010)
Mark: thanks for the upper seal removal tip. However, nearly all the info posted here about seal replacement is about doing it on the "bench," not in chassis. Despite it being obviously more difficult, do you have any advice on reinstalling an upper seal, neoprene or rope type, in the car? Thanks




My friend did it with the engine in the car. If i remember correctly, you do have to unbolt the idler arm to drop the suspension so you can remove the pan. You have to unloosen the crank so it can drop down a little so its easier to get the upper seal in.



Some tips I picked up off the net and magazine articles.



Do not put any RTV on the ends of the main seal



Make sure the lip of the main seal points in.



Put a small bead of RTV (Ultra grade) in the corners of the block where the retainer rests. (smidgen)



Put some RTV between the bolt head and the washer of the retainer bolts.



Put a dab of RTV on the end of the side seals before inserting to make sure the bottom (actually the top) is sealed. You could also put some in the channel before inserting the side seal.



Hope these help
By oldcarmark - 15 Years Ago
Good suggestions Paul2748.One more reminder as Ted mentions in his article, make sure to put the neoprene crankshaft seals in with an end sticking up a little.  In other words its not installed like the rope one with the ends level with the block.