SANTA,S BEEN.


http://209.208.111.198/Topic53215.aspx
Print Topic | Close Window

By aussiebill - 15 Years Ago
Well santa couldnt make it last year but he arrived with my new aluminum heads today, the ports look great and am still checking them out.Smile

MERRY XMAS TO ALL OUR FELLOW Y BLOCKERS. REGARDS BILL & DAUGHTER MADISON.

By LON - 15 Years Ago
Gee Bill , you  must have been a real good boy this year ???? I don't suppose you saw  my name  on Santa's  list ????. Hope to get one of those "Doc Eaton " 375 cu in  Texas Specials .Just hope the big fella doesn't hurt his back putting it under the tree ???

Best Wishes ,Merry Christmas .

Lon .

PS . Finally got the Thunderbird registered last Friday .Just need the rain to stop ,so we can drive it .

By Moz - 15 Years Ago
hey lon

i think our side of oz needs to invest in scuba gear haha merry christmas to you & lynne

bill merry christmas to you & madison

By aussiebill - 15 Years Ago
Best Xmas wishes lon & lyn, i would like to see the 375 er, better put a winch above the chimney,ha,ha.

Yes its been a long wait for them and i paid in advance for them when our $ was low, never dreaming we would be even money at this time, plus customs got them and 2 weeks of paper work and another $300.00 i got them yesterday. i am pleased with the port designs but a bit lost on the machined finish on the decks, looks like i,ve got a set of semi finished decks which will mean more unnecessary expense to fix them, so much for out of the box heads!. I hope to get through to john m this morning, will keep trying. On a happier note, i,ve got my new blown hot rod fired up and have about 2 weeks work to go.Smile best regards bill.

By Canadian Hot Rodder - 15 Years Ago
Lon, only GOOD boys get presents like that!!!! The way you operate, maybe you can figure out how to run a Y on coal................. seeing as you have a lifetime supply!!!! Tongue
By Oldmics - 15 Years Ago
Please let us know on how the rough finish gets resolved.

Oldmics

By aussiebill - 15 Years Ago
Well ,all i can tell you is that john said " its ok" and dont think he was that interested? I didnt want to get offside with him by airing this on the forum but feel after 40 years of engine building all makes, and a qualified fitter & machinist that 3 different levels of cuts on any mating surface is not the usual finish that i,ve ever seen as "ok". Why do we recut block decks and cyl heads before assy, to ensure good mating surfaces!

I had expected normal full width machine cut in one plane as in his pictured add, not like i got, and hence my concern, unfortunatly theres one cut line through center of combustion chambers where the narrowest sealing area is. Any way i,ll disasemble them and send out for machining, where they require a lot of setting up as they way different to local heads that are regularly machined.

1st pic is johns advertised heads and rest are mine, maybe i,m wrong??

  

 

  

By rick55 - 15 Years Ago
I'm with you Bill. They certainly need machining. Must have been an off day for the bloke working the head surfacing equipment.

But you have to admit they look way too good to be hidden under a bonnet - (hood for our American cousins)

Hope you had a good Xmas and will speak with you in the New Year.

Regards
By Ol'ford nut - 14 Years Ago
Any update?
By aussiebill - 14 Years Ago
Hi, i,m waiting till xmas break is over and things go back to normal when i,ll get them machined, perhaps if you,r have any queries on the finish if you are getting a set , ask john.Smile

regards bill.

By Oldmics - 14 Years Ago
I for one would like to see John"s input regarding these units.

Oldmics

By The Master Cylinder - 14 Years Ago
Wow, After all the work that has obviously gone into the heads it is a little disheartening to see that, and especially to be be sent so far. Sorry to see that, hope everything comes out OK.
By Grizzly - 14 Years Ago
Unfortunately we see it all the time. Companies sending second rate parts to the colonies. Buggar it's from Mummert and to someone like Bill. The postage is a restrictive thing. As to fix any problem you end up paying at least double, in postage, to what you should because you need to send it back. It's why a lot of people selling parts will not deal with people OS.

Definitely one that John Mummert should have responded to and one that potential buyers will be looking at.

  

By Y block Billy - 14 Years Ago
Just ask John for some new ones and send those to me!
By davis - 14 Years Ago
how was this head machining issue resolved?


By aussiebill - 14 Years Ago
We will be machining heads in the next few weeks, thank you.
By unibodyboy - 14 Years Ago
We're looking for a non political response Smile


By speedpro56 - 14 Years Ago
Aussiebill, A couple thousands will fix them up just like it did to mine. Mine are kicking BUTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!! on my 312 + going into my 56 mercury montclair conv.BigGrin
By Oldmics - 14 Years Ago
Gary

Just so that I am clear on the condition of your heads upon reciept,your new heads out of the box had to be machined at additional expense to be useable?

Oldmics

By The Master Cylinder - 14 Years Ago
Were both of your heads machined like that? Not that it makes a whole lot of difference, they both have to be machined anyway. I was just curious.



Surprised John hasn't responded...
By speedpro56 - 14 Years Ago
Same marks that Bills had. They ran fine the way they were but when I tore the engine down for a complete redo my engine builder suddested they be milled enough to clean up the marks especially the one between the cylinder. Cheap insurance that I agree with.
By John Mummert - 14 Years Ago
Since I guess this is a big deal it will be addressed. The heads shown on our website were machined in the exact same way but sanded with 220 grit psa discs stuck to a flat plate.

The step measures .0015" and was common on many aftermarket aluminum heads for years.

As Gary pointed out his heads worked fine and a .003" cut cleared up all marks meaning the step was significantly less than that.

All that having been said, since we have had complaints about the machining all future heads will be cut with an 18" face mill in a single cut. This will lead to delays and additional expense (read higher price) but I guess that is required.

The face mill for our surfacing machine has been sent out for sharpening and we need to build a fixture to hold the heads so they can be surfaced in a production manor.

By speedpro56 - 14 Years Ago
Actually it only took .002 cut and they were as good as new. The milling marks are so mi nute there were no problems showing up at all with the heads or gaskets when removed from the engine. The only reason we cleaned them up was they were off the engine and it was an easy fix at that point and here again you fill alittle better when things are as near perfect as you can get them in an imperfect world.
By speedpro56 - 14 Years Ago
I didn't get to finish what I wanted to say because my computer was acting up but to carry on what i was saying is the fact that John is doing an outstanding job on these heads. When a set goes on your engine you WILL fill it in the seat of your pants so grab your rearend or butt whatever you want to call it and hang on!!!!!!!!!
By pegleg - 14 Years Ago
I've resisted commenting on this because John's a friend of mine, and I don't want to add fuel to a fire between Bill and John.

   I made and sold aluminum cylinder heads, blocks and manifolds for 35 + years. For what it's worth, we produced parts for Ford, GM, and Chrysler, along with overseas auto companies including Weslake and Cosworth. We made parts for Jr. Johnson and Holley Carb.  

   There is no problem with the way Johns heads were done. A small step in the range that we are talking about is a non-issue. It will seal.

  What we've done here is forced John to purchase or source a very expensive mill and cutters to correct a problem that's only a visual issue. Many aluminum parts are used that will have cutter marks deeper than what the conversation is about. They will seal too. We've waited for ten or twelve years for this product, PLEASE don't kill the project with personal opinions that are not a performance or functional issue.   

By charliemccraney - 14 Years Ago
The best case here, then is to not re-tool, but to include a note with the heads stating in essence that they are fine. With products such as this, many of the customers will not be educated about the machining process, and what is and is not acceptable. With what I knew before this thread, I would have had the same reaction as Bill. Now that I know better, it is fine. Just make a note stating that they are fine as is, in order to avoid future confusion.
By The Master Cylinder - 14 Years Ago
I agree with what Charlie suggests but would like to add that if SOMEBODY had responded to this post before a month had pasted maybe most of this speculation by the non-machinists in this group (me included) would not have happened... Just my 1¢.
By aussiebill - 14 Years Ago
Thanks frank and all the other guys for their delicate input into my reaction on the machining finish of these heads, 1st of all i regard johns efforts highly and as a friend, as with everyone else here!!!! I felt my reply from john was less than satisfying and gingerly sought ideas and comparisons from the guys running these heads, i think i have the right to do this no matter how others may percieve it, the reactions  were favourable and at last john added that his advertised pictured heads had the marks lightly sanded flat, why was that? obviously it is far more how normally machined heads or decked blocks should look, had mine been finished this way, i,m sure i wouldnt have any questions, fair enough!

I dont feel i have caused john to spend more money to sort this out, if anyone wanting heads and like the heads this way tell him and he wont have to do it!!!!

Also " not wanting to get offside with john" as quoted was also a major consideration and human nature as it is may be so? but i,m sure john can see both sides of this. 

I posted this but after rereading it, i thought stuff it!  Frank, or anybody else! just say i used these heads as they were and for whatever reason the gasket blew between the cyls, i would immediatly conclude the groove contributed to it as normal heads are flat looking and after the massive expense , its nearly twice the US price! the new head may? burn a groove through it and its gone , with no comeback. thats WHY i asked about this! and i dont care how many things you or anybody else has made, the,re my heads!! And why i have to justify myself to anybody is beyond me!!

I again reiterate! This was and is not a personal attack on john but as i explained above. thank you.Smile

By pegleg - 14 Years Ago
Bill,

         That was not an attack on anybody, especially you. I am simply trying to explain that the step you see won't create a problem sealing. No-one is questioning your right to complain, but I am trying to take some heat out of the discussion. I would imagine, and I've not talked to John, that the sanding was done to make the photo look better. But again, it really won't hurt the seal........honest.

        I mentioned my work history so you'd understand that I've see this before, and have seen the results. I understand you don't care about that, but i wanted it clear that I have a little experience there. I'll admit, it looks bad. But it isn't.