Cooling overhaul


http://209.208.111.198/Topic7485.aspx
Print Topic | Close Window

By 56-Vicky - 18 Years Ago
Hey all,

I think I need to replace my radiator. I had it repaired at a shop that didn't do a good job, it still leaks a little and I'm having cooling problems.  They pinched of a couple of the channels and they are still leaking.

I see one listed at T-bird Products for $440.  It says it is a heavy duty 4 core, but I want to make sure i get the best product for the $.

Can some of you experts Cool help me out?  Do you think this is the best solution for the price?  Or has anyone found good product that takes little/no modifications and looks original?

On the same topic I see a fiberglass fan shroud listed on T-bird products for a 55-57 T-bird for $60.  Will that fit my 56 Victoria? Or can you point me in the right direction where I can get one? 

I'm also planning on ordering one of the 6 blade heavy duty 17" fans. Has anyone tried them?

What about electric fans? Are they effective? If someone has one that works well please share the details. I'd love to have one for parades etc.

I need to get something done this winter since I over heated several times this summer while idling in traffic.

Thanks!!

By John F - 18 Years Ago
I wouldn't suggest pincing off any tubes. I had a radiator shop recore my 59 Ford radiator, it cost $300. It runs cool, even on hot days. Also make sure your thermostat is working. Good luck! 

Y-Blocks Rule

John F

By carl - 18 Years Ago
Andrew I havent had any dealings with the following man but a friend has and he was satisfied with his radiator. Nvnzio Picarella  7438 vanport ave, whittier  ca 90606   phone #562 693 8197  i dont know his prices good luck   Carl
By Pete 55Tbird - 18 Years Ago
Andrew. Nice car. Now about the overheating, just some thoughts. First, use a 180 degree thermostat. This provides quick warm up and has NOTHING TO DO WITH OVERHEATING, NOTHING. If you have some car savy friends ask them to recomend a radiator shop to recore your radiator and get a FIRM price for 3 or 4 row recore. Then you KNOW it fits. I use the 6 blade fan and I like it. USE A SHROUD, the blades of your engine driven fan should be just aft of the shroud. Use a catch can and a 14 lb radiator cap and a 70 / 30 water antifreeze mix and a WATER WETTER. Before all this FLUSH your cooling system. If you still overheat in parades an elect fan will take 10/17 amps to run and should have a RELAY in the system. AS to $440 for a Tbird radiator well check an ALUMINUM radiator FIRST, if you are not going stock. ALUMINUM is THE BEST CHOICE. Let us know. Pete
By paul2748 - 18 Years Ago
A recommended thermostat is the #6 NAPA. High flow, 170 degrees. I have a 54 Ford, 312 with the stock radiator, the NAPA thermostat and a four blade fan located within a half inch of the radiator - has never gone over 190 degrees in very hot weather.
By Tom Compton - 18 Years Ago
I believe my book says Mr. Ford recommends a 7# cap.  Will check after church,  Ted Eaton recommended a 7# unit for my recent build.

Check w/ Lance at Thunderbirds Southwest for radiator and fan shroud.  I got my larger anti sway bars there.

"Lance" <tbirdandfordparts@fais.net>

TC

By Nick Brann - 18 Years Ago
Hey Andrew, Nice car.  I had one like it back in the 60's, wish I had it back.  You would be wise to get a 16" electric fan, pusher type is supposed to be more efficient, should be enough room in front of your radiator.  The A/C experts that I know say to get a Spal fan, that's the brand name.  The other brands don't last, I've been told.  Like Pete said, a 180-degree thermostat is better than a 160 or 170.  NAPA has a high-flow (large opening) 180-degree in their line, p/n is 106.  I've been using one for about 4 years now.  Good luck, Nick Brann
By paul2748 - 18 Years Ago
Not to dispute Nick, but I have heard that a puller (rear of radiator) is more efficient. This would seem the more likely, as there is nothing in front of the radiator to stop flow.
By PF Arcand - 18 Years Ago
Andrew; If you just had the Rad repaired and it's still leaking, take it back!..Have it redone or get your money back.. As for all the "ad on aids" for the cooling system, it seems to me you need to get at the root of the problem. 56 Fords are not noted for overheating. So, most likely your system needs a complete flush. Then as mentioned ensure your thermostat is installed properly & functioning. It's also possible but unlikely, you have a failed head gasket, so do the other stuff first.   
By 56-Vicky - 18 Years Ago
Hey Guys,
Appreciate all the help/info.  I've taken all of it and tried to put it to good use. 

I finished the restore about 2 years ago and have 1200 miles on it since then.  It really isn't over heating bad, I may have not described it well.  It runs fine but on 100+ days at idle for a while (like in a parade) it pegs hot. Once opened up on the road it cools down pretty good. But it's a little annoying to have to worry about it and worry that if I get stuck somewhere I may have to pull over and shut it down.

What is really brining this to a head is that it is now dripping water from a few spots in the radiator...

After I put the radiator in and then finished the restore 6 months later, I noticed that it was leaking a little. I took it back that same day but the shop was cleaned out and gone... so no luck on warranty.

I took it for a drive this Sunday and popped the hood afterward and it was dripping pretty fast from the upper hose.  When i looked closer it is leaking around where the neck comes out for the hose (apart from where the pinched and soldered a tube).  I also noticed it is sweating around the joints on the tank.  So I decided to scrap the idea of a recore and ordered the new 4 core from T-bird Products.  I toyed with going aluminum but want to keep as much of a stock look as I can.  I also ordered the 6 blade fan.

I looked back at my records and I put a 160 degree thermostat in.  Do you think there is a large enough benefit in pulling it out for a 180 while I have the radiator out? I Probably will do it and give it a good flush as suggested.

I also found only 1 place that sells shrouds for the 56 full size car. I found LOTS of T-bird and truck shrouds but had a hard time finding one for my car. (www.ThunderbirdSouthwest.com Owner Lance Harrington $170)

For the electric fan, I did some more lookin and poking around on the web.  They are pretty pricey so I may wait on that and see how this other stuff works. BUT, want to see if anyone can comment on using a shroud for it or not. 

I don't think it would be wise to use a shroud because I plan to mount a pusher on the front of the radiator.  It seems it would block all the air from flowing into the radiator.

If I end up doing it I would probably just mount a simple fan on the front.

Thanks again!

By 56-Vicky - 18 Years Ago
That's good to know!  Any suggestions on a more accurate guage that I could hide somewhere (maybe under the dash) that is simple to install?

Would a new guage be able to use the sensor unit in the block or does it require installing a new sensor?

By Daniel Jessup - 18 Years Ago
Andy,

don't know if you have followed my old post about installing one of those new 4 core radiators in my 55, but please be careful and check and recheck the clearance before you put it in. I noticed my new radiator was just too deep and I had to do some judicious "customizing" to get the install right - it looks and works fine, but that was after I had the spacer machined and I ground down my water pump shaftw00t. Hopefully you won't have any trouble and it will be a simple swap.Smile

Dan

By 56-Vicky - 18 Years Ago
Daniel,

Yeah, I saw your post when I started this whole thing.  I'll be sure to check it all out BEFORE starting the engine.

Thanks again for the heads up!

By speedpro56 - 18 Years Ago
I installed a 4 row in my 56 sunliner with no problems, my 56 had had the small spacer behind the fan and that may be why it went in with a perfect fit.Cool
By pegleg - 18 Years Ago
Andy,

        Re the gage question, two or three thoughts, A new under dash gage will come with it's own sender. I prefer electrics, they're simple to install and considerably more accurate than the original 51 year old stocker. you will have to find a place to install the sender. Close to the thermostat will be the hottest part of the system 2) there are a number of instrument shops that can re-build and re-calabrate the original gage. 3) You can check it youself with the new aftermarket gage, and see if it needs to be re-adjusted. Most likely, as John Said, it's wrong.   

By unibodyboy - 18 Years Ago
Frank,



When you say that the highest temperature will be closest to the thermostat, how much of a difference can this make? My sending unit is sitting behind the intake on the top of the block. I was concerned I was running too cool @ 165-170(good gauge) however could I really be running about right and have my sending unit too far away from the highest point?


By pegleg - 18 Years Ago
Greg, Not much from the front to the back. I think your present sender is located on the back of the right hand head now. Should be another plugged hole in the crossover at the front of the intake, you could use that.
By GREENBIRD56 - 18 Years Ago
I don't think there is a "downside" to putting your temp sensor at the same spot the factory did (driverside rear). If your engine is happy with the operating temperature as it is right now - if it is stable and you have tuned the induction system for it - there shouldn't be an issue (unless you get cold feet in the winter) with the temp you've got.

Seems to me a classic way to check the system capacity is to remove the thermostat (or put in a washer with a thermostat poppet sized hole) - then run the system in the hottest conditions. Once the system volume has reached stability (thermal expansion stops running excess water out of the radiator cap bypass) and if you aren't overpressuring the standard cap with steam -  you've basically proved the system is adequate to cool the engine. If it overheats with no thermostat restriction, the pump capacity is too small or the radiator is too small or stuffed or there isn't enough fan - or maybe your engine is building a non-typical amount of heat (like way retarded timing while idling in a parade or traffic). Something will have to be improved or fixed.

Assuming stability, a check of water temp (at the thermostat housing) versus outdooor ambient will then tell you what the system "rise" is with the equipment you've got. You can then install a thermostat to raise the temperature up to where you want it. 

By DANIEL TINDER - 18 Years Ago
Andrew;



In case you still have the '56 double diaphragm Loadomatic distributor, I met a guy last weekend with a '56 Bird who traced his severe overheating problem to the retarded timing that resulted when that system malfunctioned. I also heard those parts are VERY hard to find.
By 56-Vicky - 18 Years Ago
Well, I got the radiator and 6 blade fan yesterday and put it in this morning.  I flushed it out really well.  It went well but was too wide for the existing spacer as Dan mentioned.  I milled it down but it was still too much.  I finally left it out completely and it is about 3/4" - 1" from the radiator. I'll throw some washers in there and put it to the 1/2" next week.  I had to go buy some shorter bolts for the fan since the stock bolts bottomed out.

I also put in the 180* high flow (#106) thermostat.  All seems well so far, I took it out on a test drive and as the guage reached the mid point, the thermostat opened and it stayed right there at the midpoint.

I also checked the timing and it is right on and seems that advance is still working well.

Thanks again for all the help.  I'll run it this way and tackle the other suggestions if it heats up again.

By the way, it's finally cruising weather again here and I'm loving every second of it!! BigGrin

By marvh - 18 Years Ago
I also found only 1 place that sells shrouds for the 56 full size car. I found LOTS of T-bird and truck shrouds but had a hard time finding one for my car. (www.ThunderbirdSouthwest.com Owner Lance Harrington $170)



For the electric fan, I did some more lookin and poking around on the web. They are pretty pricey so I may wait on that and see how this other stuff works. BUT, want to see if anyone can comment on using a shroud for it or not.



I don't think it would be wise to use a shroud because I plan to mount a pusher on the front of the radiator. It seems it would block all the air from flowing into the radiator.



If I end up doing it I would probably just mount a simple fan on the front.



Thanks again!

[/quote]



The shroud will not fit the full size cars if you have power steering as the belt is in the way.

marv
By Daniel Jessup - 18 Years Ago
Just a thought about the electric fans. You may want to give Northern Auto Parts a shout - from what I have seen, they do have reasonable prices. Also check out Speedway Motors.

Sorry to hear about your install - I don't know what the issues are here, but I called the company that I bought it from (Autocity out in MN), and they said they have not heard of any troubles????? The radiator does cool well though - I like it!Cool

Dan

By Pete 55Tbird - 18 Years Ago
On the subject of electric fans. The Mustang and   the Jeep and off road guys are very high on the factory fan from the 3.8 Taurus. The two speed fan that has 3 wires and is 18 wide x 21 high. It is only a puller and on high it move a HUGH QUANITY of air but it also draws lots of amps, anywhere from 12 to 17. I just picked one up for $40 and the local pick u part sells them for around that. They have a shroud as part of the mount and are under 4 1/2 inch deep. On a 56 you could mount it ahead of the radiator as a puller with some fabrication. Pete
By 56-Vicky - 18 Years Ago
Hey guys, been a few days since I was able to log on. My 1 year old duaghter broke her arm and had to have surgery Sad

Anyway, I got the new radiator, 6 blade fan and shroud on yesterday.  Now I'd like to get a good guage to see what temp I'm REALLY running. 

Can anyone suggest a good guage and which ones to stay away from?

Thanks!

By paul2748 - 18 Years Ago
If you are going to run an electric fan, use a puller with a shroud. I think Spall makes them that way, at least I saw some manufacturer's advertisement in the street rodder books that way.



You might want to thoroughly clean out the block water passages. I understand ordinary vinegar does a very good job.
By rgrove - 18 Years Ago
FWIW, I have had the 4-row from T-Bird on my 292 equipped '56 for several years, and it has always run a bit on the COOL side, even without a shoroud, and with the OE 4-blade fan.  Only tim eit gets much above the t-stat temp (180) at all is after a LOT of idling in a long parade on a very hot day, but even then , nowhere near boil over - I think the highest temp I have seen is about 200 or 205, tops.  ever.  You may want to try that for a while and see how it goes before you add extra fans, shrouds, etc.

Oh, I am also running a 13lbs cap - should lower that just to relieve some pressure....YMMV

By Hoosier Hurricane - 18 Years Ago
Andrew:

When you get your new radiator in, if you don't loose coolant when the gauge reads hot, it is probably not hurting anything.  '56 gauges are not known to be very accurate, and vary from car to car.  Good luck.

John