Mark - Regarding the Holley carb
You shouldn't have to open the primary throttle to the point that the ported vacuum is active at idle. The throttle stop should hold the primary butterfles so that the idle transfer slot shows as a "square" viewed from underneath. I believe you've got the mixture needles all set-up by now, they should be withdrawn from "stop" a full turn or more - correct? I don't know about you - but it is very hard for me to keep myself from playing with the primary throttle stop - but it will screw up the transfer slot / primary butterfly relationship every time. And you will get what you've got - other carburetor circuits are becoming active and defeating your opportunity to tune it.
On the carb, viewed from the bottom, there is a small set screw located beneath the vacuum secondary pot that functions as the "stop" for the secondary butterfly shaft. There is a "fixed" idle fuel supply available to the secondary and opening the butterflies a slight amount will provide fuel/air to the engine. Because the little inverted set screw is a pain to access - I usually resort to bending the little sheet metal tab above it with needle nose pliers a tiny amount. Often - this will allow setting the primary stop screw where you want it and provide idle air/ fuel to run the engine. Using this technique - leave the distributor vacuum line open and the two carb vacuum points that might feed it, plugged.
Another "air supply" for the engine is the PCV - it should be regulating itself as far as air flow - but the carb has to supply fuel for that air source as well. If you plug that PCV port on the carb - and fully tune the engine, hooking up the PCV to the valley later on will screw up your idle tuning - so it needs to be on there and working. Also make sure the choke system is out of your way and not providing a false "stop " for the primary - holding it open.
Tweaking the tab under the secondary should make it possible to get the engine running - with the primary stop located as desired - and get the engine speed into a useful idle set-up range. And you should be able then to unplug and "test" the ported vacuum source and find no vacuum.
The distributor should be able to hold your "initial" advance and always return there - if not - there is a mechanical reason that must be found.
Steve Metzger Tucson, Arizona